Selling Your Cards, Games and Hobby Collections

At Lots Moore Craft and Gaming, we offer store credit in exchange for eligible Magic: The Gathering cards, wargaming miniatures, boardgames, roleplaying books and tabletop gaming accessories.

Whether you're making room for something new or moving on from an old collection, we're happy to assess what you have.

Please read the following information before selling your items to us.

Magic: The Gathering Cards

Important Information

• Store Credit Only: We offer store credit in exchange for cards. We do not offer cash payments.

• All Sales Are Final: Once we have purchased your cards, the sale is final. We are not obligated to return your cards to you. If you wish to reacquire cards you have sold to us, you may be required to purchase them back at their current store value.

• Card Ownership: You must own the cards you submit or be authorised to sell them on behalf of the owner.

• Store Account Required: You must have a store account so we can issue your store credit.

• Card Condition: We accept cards in any condition, although we prefer cards in good condition. Individual card prices are based on Mint condition guidelines. Cards in lower conditions may receive a reduced offer.

• Assessment: We will assess the cards you bring in and may adjust quantities or conditions, which may affect the final offer.

• Processing Time: Please allow up to 7 days for us to assess your cards and issue your store credit. If we need more time, we will contact you.

• Market Fluctuations: We are not responsible for changes in card market values before, during or after the exchange.

• Right to Decline: We reserve the right to decline any card or buylist. Any cards we decline will be returned to you, except where an applicable law or our Counterfeits Policy requires otherwise.

• Counterfeit Cards: All cards sold to us must be genuine, including cards submitted individually or as bulk. Staff may inspect cards and refuse a transaction if a card's authenticity is uncertain. Suspected counterfeit cards will be assessed before any action is taken. Confirmed counterfeit cards will be destroyed without compensation and will not be returned, to prevent them from re-entering circulation. For more information, please refer to our Counterfeits Policy.

Individual Card Buylist (Buylists are closed, but will open in 2027)

We may offer up to 60% of a card's market value when purchasing individual cards. BinderPOS is used to determine market value.

The final offer depends on several factors, including:

• The card's condition.

• Its current market value.

• Whether the card is in demand or something we want for our store.

Submitting a buylist online does not guarantee that we will purchase every card or pay the displayed value. All cards are subject to in-store assessment.

How to Submit a Buylist (Buylists are closed, but will open in 2027)

1. Visit our website and select the Buylist tab.

2. Add the cards you wish to sell and submit your buylist online.

3. Bring your cards into the store for assessment.

Our staff cannot create buylists for you in-store. You must submit your buylist online before bringing your cards in.

We may decline buylists containing large quantities of low-value cards and ask you to submit those cards as bulk instead. These cards can still be assessed under our bulk pricing rates.

Bulk Card Pricing

We offer the following rates for bulk Magic: The Gathering cards:

What We Accept as Bulk

Unsorted bulk may include any type of Magic: The Gathering card, including any rarity, basic lands and tokens. We do not accept non-Magic cards as bulk.

The minimum value for bulk submissions is 50c in store credit. Submissions must meet this minimum to be accepted. Partial quantities are paid proportionally. For example, 500 unsorted cards would receive $2.50 in store credit.

For the sorted bulk rates, cards must be separated into the appropriate categories, sorted by set, unsleeved and facing the same direction.

If cards do not fully fit the criteria of a sorted category, we will consider them to be Unsorted Bulk. E.g. If you have sleeved rares and mythics that are facing different directions, we will consider them to be Unsorted Bulk. 

All bulk submissions are subject to assessment by our staff.

If we are hosting an event or assisting other customers, we may ask you to arrange an appointment or return at a quieter time.

Selling a Collection

If you have a large collection or would like assistance preparing your cards for sale, you can contact us by phone or email to arrange an appointment.

Collections of 20,000 cards or more: Please contact us beforehand to organise an appointment so we can ensure we have enough time to assess your collection.

We are happy to help you understand the process and work out the best way to submit your collection for assessment.

Wargaming Miniatures, Boardgames and Tabletop Gaming

At Lots Moore Craft and Gaming, we offer store credit in exchange for eligible wargaming miniatures, boardgames, roleplaying books and tabletop gaming accessories.

Please read the following information before selling your items to us.

Important Information

• Store Credit Only: We offer store credit in exchange for items. We do not offer cash payments.

• All Sales Are Final: Once we have purchased your items, the sale is final. We are not obligated to return them to you. If you wish to reacquire items you have sold to us, you may be required to purchase them back at their current store value.

• Item Ownership: You must own the items you submit or be authorised to sell them on behalf of the owner.

• Store Account Required: You must have a store account so we can issue your store credit.

• Item Condition: We consider items in a range of conditions, although we prefer items in good condition. Damage, excessive wear, missing components or other issues may reduce the offer or result in an item being declined.

• Assessment: We will inspect and assess your items before making an offer. We may adjust quantities, conditions or valuations, which may affect the final offer.

• Processing Time: Please allow up to 7 days for us to assess your items and issue your store credit. If we need more time, we will contact you.

• Market Fluctuations: We are not responsible for changes in market values before, during or after the exchange.

• Right to Decline: We reserve the right to decline any item or collection. Any items we decline will be returned to you, except where applicable law requires otherwise.

• Authenticity: We only accept genuine products. Staff may inspect items and refuse a transaction if their authenticity is uncertain. Suspected counterfeit items will be assessed before any action is taken. Confirmed counterfeit items will be destroyed without compensation and will not be returned, to prevent them from re-entering circulation. For more information, please refer to our Counterfeits Policy.

Wargaming Miniatures

We consider genuine, commercially manufactured wargaming miniatures from a range of tabletop gaming systems.

3D-Printed Miniatures: We do not accept 3D-printed miniatures or 3D-printed components, regardless of their quality, condition or intended use.

The final offer depends on several factors, including:

• The brand and game system.

• The condition of the miniatures.

• Whether models are assembled, unassembled or painted.

• Whether all components and parts are included.

• The current market value and availability.

• Whether the models are in demand or something we want for our store.

Painted, assembled and partially assembled miniatures may be accepted, although their condition and quality of assembly or painting may affect the final offer.

Incomplete kits, damaged miniatures and models with missing components may receive a reduced offer or be declined.

Boardgames

We consider a range of new and pre-owned boardgames for purchase.

Complete Games Only: Boardgames must include all original components and contents to be eligible for purchase. We do not accept incomplete games or games with missing components.

The final offer depends on several factors, including:

• The game's overall condition.

• The condition of the box, cards, boards and other components.

• The game's current market value and availability.

• Whether the game is in demand or something we want for our store.

Games must be in reasonable condition, with all original components present and accounted for. Excessively damaged or heavily worn games may receive a reduced offer or be declined.

We may ask to inspect the contents of a game before making an offer. Please ensure games are organised and all components are included before bringing them in.

Roleplaying Books and Accessories

We may consider a range of roleplaying game (RPG) books and related accessories for purchase, including Dungeons & Dragons books and products from other tabletop roleplaying systems.

Items may include:

• Core rulebooks, supplements and campaign books.

• Adventure modules and sourcebooks.

• Dice and dice accessories.

• Character sheets, accessories and gaming aids.

• Other tabletop roleplaying products.

The final offer depends on several factors, including:

• The book or product's condition.

• The edition and game system.

• Whether the product is complete.

• Its current market value and availability.

• Whether the item is in demand or something we want for our store.

Books with excessive damage, missing pages or significant wear may receive a reduced offer or be declined. Accessories must be in reasonable condition and include any essential components.

Not all products will be eligible for purchase. Please contact us if you are unsure whether we would be interested in something.

Selling a Collection

If you have a large collection of wargaming miniatures, boardgames or roleplaying products, or would like assistance preparing your items for sale, you can contact us by phone or email to arrange an appointment.

Large collections may require additional assessment time. Please contact us beforehand so we can ensure we have enough time to assess your items.

If we are hosting an event or assisting other customers, we may ask you to arrange an appointment or return at a quieter time.

We are happy to help you understand the process and work out the best way to submit your collection for assessment.